September 9, 2007

by Reb Yudel
My Podhoretz Problem (and ours)

Andy Sullivan links to what may be the key paragraphs in the New York Review of Books takedown of Podhoretz:
When Podhoretz grew up in Brooklyn, the common assumption was that Jews were rich and Negroes were persecuted. This was not how things looked to Podhoretz on the playground of his local public school, where poor Jewish boys like him were regularly being beaten up by Negroes: "There is a fight, they win, and we retreat, half whimpering, half with bravado. My first experience of cowardice." Negroes, he goes on, "made one feel inadequate. But most important of all, they were tough, beautifully, enviably tough, not giving a damn for anyone or anything.... This is what I envied and feared in the Negro...." And then there were the effete snobs, "the writers and intellectuals and artists who romanticize the Negroes, and pander to them," and "all the white liberals who permit the Negroes to blackmail them into adopting a double standard of moral judgment...."

The key to Podhoretz's politics seems to me to lie right there: the longing for power, for toughness, for the Shtarker who doesn't give a damn about anyone or anything, and hatred of the contemptible, cowardly liberals with their pandering ways and their double standards. Since Podhoretz, himself a bookish man, can never be a Shtarker, his government must fill that role, and not give a damn about anyone or anything. And not only the US government, but Israel too.




Powered by ScribeFire.

TrackBack
Comments
#1

Kahane went the shtarker route, but also wanted Israel to not give a damn. Moral: Be bookish, live long?

Posted by: David H. at September 24, 2007 9:53 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?


type the word "captcha" (you would rather decode a crazy picture?)